...according to our Ant on Fri 11 Feb, 2011.
The third installment in this series paying homage to Dan Treacy's legendary group has landed and it is packed with 23 tracks and also comes with a bonus disc. Folks involved include The Years, Anorak Girl, Blue Petal, The Model Spy, JP Bartlett, A Smile & A Ribbon, Sarandon, The Painted Word, Amida, Boyracer, Apple Orchard, Cineplexx, Bunny Grunt and tons of other people I cant be bothered to type out so go check out the item page on the site. The bonus disc also has 23 tunes (so that's 46 in total for any of you that failed miserably at mathematics). This disc has Babybee, The Nomen, Neil Mooney, The Pristines, Golden Teardrops, The Puddle, Humdrum, Palmflower and a host of other bands I now totally cannot be bothered typing in case my fingers fall off.
Canadian indie label The Beautiful Music has committed itself to releasing ten Television Personalities tribute albums over the next few years. It is an idea that is both bonkers and admirable, as if the label is trying to make up for all the praise and recognition that the band has sadly missed out on over its 30 plus year existence. Tribute albums are often quite hit and miss, but for TVPs fans, the songs are familiar and much loved, and several bands offer a fun and different take on the song they perform. After the Years’ spiky version of ‘This Angry Silence’, Anorak Girl take a kitschy electro pop approach to ‘Smashing Time’ It sort of sounds like a solo effort from the girls from the Human League, which is great, and seems to suit the song.
Blue Petal’s arrangement of ‘A Good and Faithful Servant’ is fairly faithful to the original, slowing it down and giving it a swinging, waltzy beat, but capturing the sentiment of the song nicely.
A Smile And A Ribbon’s take on ‘Magnificent Dreams’ sounds a bit Electrelane-like, and has a nice innocent, childish vibe to it.
Sarandon take ‘And Don’t the Kids Just Love It’ and sharpen up the 60s garage rock influence within it, making it more overt. The Painted Word unsurprisingly takes ‘The Painted Word’ and adds a breakbeat to it, which, with the Beatles-ish backwards guitar and tambourine, makes it sound a bit like an early Britpop song. Good on them for being daring and trying something a bit different though.
Amica’s loose, de-anglified version of ‘In a Perfumed Garden’ reminds me a little of Pavement, and therefore gets two thumbs up.
Armstrong’s nice harmonies and simple, arrangement of ‘This Heart’s Not Made of Stone’ is another highlight; different enough from the original to stand up on its own, but keeping the sentiment of the original.
Cineplexx gives ‘I Hope You Have a Nice Day’ a sort of lo fi Phil Spector treatment, while Apple Orchard strips away the 80s jangle of ‘The Dream Inspires’ and replaces it with Sloan-meets- Belle and Sebastian indie pop.
La Grande Illusion Gainsbourg-ifies ‘Glittering Prizes’; it’s unexpected, but surprisingly good. The alt-rock version of ‘The Man Who Paints the Rainbows’, supplied by the oddly-named Bunnygrunt, is another good one; it’s a natural adaptation that is different but doesn’t feel
forced.
Versions of ‘This Angry Silence’ book-end the compilation, with Boyracer’s closing take making it sound very Buzzcocks-like.
A few arrangements don’t quite work, but thankfully, ‘All Those Times We Spent Together’ is more hit than miss.
Be the first to review this record. Best reviewer each month gets £10 off their next order!